[Ica-sdistandards] Contribute to a paper about the ICA model of stakeholders in an SDI?

Tue Oct 1 04:36:44 CEST 2019

Hi Antony,

are you consolidating the comments into 2 papers? If so, I prefer to wait
for the consolidated draft and contribute there (I'm also a bit behind with
other things ;-).

Another option would be Journal of Spatial Science - SDI and its aspects
are a welcome topic there.

Regards,
Ivana

On Tue, Oct 1, 2019 at 4:33 AM Antony Cooper <ACooper at csir.co.za> wrote:

> Dear Commission members
>
> Thank you all very much for your responses, which I have seen from Jan,
> Stefan, Petr, Adam, Joep, Tatiana and Ivana.  Anyone else?  It is not
> too late to contribute.
>
> Firstly, thank you very much, Petr, for converting the text into MS
> Word.  If any of you have  further comments or inputs to make, you can
> mark them up in this version.  In the interim, I will try to consolidate
> all your comments into a new version, but I am a bit behind with things
> ...
>
> Secondly, which journal should we target?  An obvious choice is IJGIS,
> as our SDI model papers were published there.  Alternatives are the
> journals connected with the ICA: International Journal of Cartography
> (IJC), The Cartographic Journal, Cartographica and Cartography and
> Geographic Information Science (CaGIS).  It is preferable now-a-days to
> publish open access, but unfortunately, all of these are closed journals
> and I do not have the funds to pay for APCs.  Do any of you?  :-)
>
> Of these, all but IJC are on the ISI list of accredited journals, for
> whom this is important (such as me).
>
> As I mentioned in Tokyo, there is also the South African Journal of
> Geomatics, which is open access and which charges no APCs because it is
> fully funded by the profits South Africa made off hosting the ICC in
> 2003.  So, it does have an ICA connection, but it is not on an ISI
> list.
>
> Thank you
> Antony
>
>
> >>> On 24 September 2019 at 09:06, in message
> <0870a840d96548d88f436e1d16eaee74 at sdfe.dk>, Jan Hjelmager
> <jnh at sdfe.dk>
> wrote:
> > Hi Antony
> > First sorry for my slow response.
> >
> > It look good. However, I have one question. Will the model change
> with the
> > emergence of IoT and SmartCity? - It will at least bring a new type
> of dynamic
> > into an SDI.
> >
> > Best regards
> > Jan
> >
> > -----Oprindelig meddelelse-----
> > Fra: Antony Cooper <ACooper at csir.co.za>
> > Sendt: 10. september 2019 11:23
> > Til: Serena Coetzee <serenacoetzee at gmail.com>;
> > Ica-sdistandards at lazarus.elte.hu; Jan Hjelmager <jnh at sdfe.dk>
> > Emne: Re: SV: [Ica-sdistandards] Contribute to a paper about the ICA
> model of
> > stakeholders in an SDI?
> >
> > Dear Jan
> >
> > The answer to both is as soon as possible, but that is probably not
> a
> > very useful answer!
> >
> > It is unlikely that we will be able to get the review paper
> published
> > in a decent journal in 2019, but I want to have submitted the paper
> by
> > the beginning of December 2019.  This should be possible, because
> the
> > paper is largely finished - particularly if we go for option (1).
> > Option (2) might be more appealing to the relevant editors, though.
> >
> > The paper was written in LaTeX using the ICC 2019 template, so it
> will
> > have to be reformatted for the journal we select, and it might need
> to
> > be converted to MS Word.  If any of you are fluent in LaTeX I can
> send
> > the source file to you, but it will be sufficient to send me your
> > comments marked up on the PDF, or as notes in an email.  I am quite
> > happy to incorporate any comments or suggestions you might have into
> the
> > text myself.
> >
> > For the moment, please try to send me your inputs by Monday 30
> > September 2019, so that I can include them in the next version.
> >
> > Regards
> > Antony
> >
> >
> >>>> On 09 September 2019 at 23:57, in message
> > <833918554cff419db284f6b3b86182a5 at sdfe.dk>, Jan Hjelmager
> > <jnh at sdfe.dk>
> > wrote:
> >> Hi Serena and Antony
> >> I have two question. What is the timeline for producing the paper,
> > and when
> >> do you need a reply as to if one can contribute?
> >>
> >> Best regards
> >> Jan
> >>
> >>
> >> Jan Hjelmager
> >> Specialist consultant
> >> Methodology and IT
> >>
> >> D. +45 7254 5115
> >> M. +45 4129 3036
> >> E. jnh at sdfe.dk<mailto:jnh at sdfe.dk>
> >>
> >> [cid:image001.png at 01D18F45.01BF1370]
> >>
> >> The Danish Agency for Data Supply and Efficiency
> >>
> >> Rentemestervej 8
> >> 2400 Copenhagen NV
> >> Denmark
> >>
> >> T. +45 7254 5500
> >> W. www.sdfe.dk<http://www.sdfe.dk/>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >> Fra: ICA-SDIStandards <ica-sdistandards-bounces at lazarus.elte.hu> På
> > vegne af
> >> Serena Coetzee
> >> Sendt: 9. september 2019 20:11
> >> Til: Ica-sdistandards at lazarus.elte.hu
> >> Emne: [Ica-sdistandards] Contribute to a paper about the ICA model
> of
> >
> >> stakeholders in an SDI?
> >>
> >> Dear Commission members,
> >>
> >> Antony Cooper, a former Chair of our Commission on SDI & Standards,
> > would
> >> like to invite Commission members to contribute to a paper about
> the
> > ICA
> >> model of stakeholders in a spatial data infrastructure (SDI). The
> > idea is
> >> that this will be a paper from our Commission, so any of you are
> > welcome to
> >> contribute.
> >>
> >> Attached is the latest version of a paper provisionally entitled "A
> > review
> >> of the ICA model of stakeholders in a spatial data infrastructure
> > (SDI)".  A
> >> preliminary version of this paper was presented at ICC 2019,
> entitled
> >
> >> "Expanding the ICA model of stakeholders in a spatial data
> > infrastructure
> >> (SDI) ".  For the abstract of that presentation, see:
> >> https://www.abstr-int-cartogr-assoc.net/1/49/2019/. The list of
> > authors for
> >> the ICC 2019 abstract is all those who worked on the model during
> the
> >
> >> Commission meeting in Dresden, August 2013.
> >>
> >> The attached paper is primarily a review of the literature that
> used
> > the
> >> Commission's SDI models and a consolidation of the suggested
> > improvements to
> >> the SDI stakeholder model.  This paper also includes a figure
> showing
> > all the
> >> 45 types and subtypes of a stakeholder in an SDI that were included
> > in the
> >> Commission's paper at ICC 2011 in Paris (a separate, larger copy of
> > the
> >> figures is also attached).  This attached paper also includes a
> table
> > from
> >> the 2008 IJGIS paper (that might or might not have any relevance)
> and
> > the
> >> expanded SDI stakeholder model from the Dresden meeting, which is
> > clearly
> >> incomplete.
> >>
> >> Going forward, there are the following options:
> >>
> >> (1) Complete this paper as a review paper, with Section 4. "Summary
> > of the
> >> suggested changes to the model" being an overview of the suggested
> > changes.
> >> The two tables will then be omitted.
> >>
> >> (2) Complete this paper as a review paper, with Section 4. "Summary
> > of the
> >> suggested changes to the model" being a consolidation of all the
> > suggestions,
> >> producing an update of the figure of the SDI stakeholders.  Again,
> > the two
> >> tables will then be omitted.
> >>
> >> (3) Split this paper into two papers, one being the review and the
> > other
> >> being the new SDI stakeholder model, incorporating all the
> suggested
> >
> >> improvements, completing Table 2: Expanded SDI stakeholder model
> (the
> > Dresden
> >> results) and producing an update of the figure of the SDI
> > stakeholders.  This
> >> second paper will take a lot more effort.
> >>
> >> If you would like to contribute to one of these papers (and hence
> be
> > a
> >> co-author), please contact Antony Cooper
> >> acooper at csir.co.za<mailto:acooper at csir.co.za>
> >>
> >> Regards,
> >> Serena
> >>
> >> Serena Coetzee (GPr GISc 1245)
> >> University of Pretoria
> >> Professor and Head of Department Geography, Geoinformatics and
> > Meteorology
> >> Geography Building 1-3.7, Hatfield Campus, Lynnwood Road, Hatfield,
> > 0083,
> >> South Africa
> >> email: serena.coetzee at up.ac.za<mailto:serena.coetzee at up.ac.za> ·
> Web:
> >
> >> www.up.ac.za/ggm<http://www.up.ac.za/ggm> · Mobile: +27 82 464 4294
> ·
> > Tel: +27
> >> 12 420 3823
> >>
> >> Stakeholder analysis of the governance framework of a national SDI
> > dataset *
> >> whose needs are met in the buildings and address register of the
> >>
> >
> Netherlands?<
> https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17538947.2018.15209
>
> >
> >>30>
> >> Geographic Information Metadata*An Outlook from the International
> >> Standardization Perspective<https://www.mdpi.com/2220-9964/8/6/280>
>
> _______________________________________________
> ICA-SDIStandards mailing list
> ICA-SDIStandards at lazarus.elte.hu
> http://lazarus.elte.hu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/ica-sdistandards
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lazarus.elte.hu/pipermail/ica-sdistandards/attachments/20191001/8041ea12/attachment-0001.html>