[Ica-sdistandards] Contribute to a paper about the ICA model of stakeholders in an SDI?

Mon Sep 30 22:33:42 CEST 2019

Dear Commission members

Thank you all very much for your responses, which I have seen from Jan,
Stefan, Petr, Adam, Joep, Tatiana and Ivana.  Anyone else?  It is not
too late to contribute.

Firstly, thank you very much, Petr, for converting the text into MS
Word.  If any of you have  further comments or inputs to make, you can
mark them up in this version.  In the interim, I will try to consolidate
all your comments into a new version, but I am a bit behind with things
...

Secondly, which journal should we target?  An obvious choice is IJGIS,
as our SDI model papers were published there.  Alternatives are the
journals connected with the ICA: International Journal of Cartography
(IJC), The Cartographic Journal, Cartographica and Cartography and
Geographic Information Science (CaGIS).  It is preferable now-a-days to
publish open access, but unfortunately, all of these are closed journals
and I do not have the funds to pay for APCs.  Do any of you?  :-)

Of these, all but IJC are on the ISI list of accredited journals, for
whom this is important (such as me).

As I mentioned in Tokyo, there is also the South African Journal of
Geomatics, which is open access and which charges no APCs because it is
fully funded by the profits South Africa made off hosting the ICC in
2003.  So, it does have an ICA connection, but it is not on an ISI
list.

Thank you
Antony

>>> On 24 September 2019 at 09:06, in message
<0870a840d96548d88f436e1d16eaee74 at sdfe.dk>, Jan Hjelmager
<jnh at sdfe.dk>
wrote:
> Hi Antony
> First sorry for my slow response.
> 
> It look good. However, I have one question. Will the model change
with the 
> emergence of IoT and SmartCity? - It will at least bring a new type
of dynamic 
> into an SDI.
> 
> Best regards
> Jan
> 
> -----Oprindelig meddelelse-----
> Fra: Antony Cooper <ACooper at csir.co.za> 
> Sendt: 10. september 2019 11:23
> Til: Serena Coetzee <serenacoetzee at gmail.com>; 
> Ica-sdistandards at lazarus.elte.hu; Jan Hjelmager <jnh at sdfe.dk>
> Emne: Re: SV: [Ica-sdistandards] Contribute to a paper about the ICA
model of 
> stakeholders in an SDI?
> 
> Dear Jan
> 
> The answer to both is as soon as possible, but that is probably not
a
> very useful answer!
> 
> It is unlikely that we will be able to get the review paper
published
> in a decent journal in 2019, but I want to have submitted the paper
by
> the beginning of December 2019.  This should be possible, because
the
> paper is largely finished - particularly if we go for option (1). 
> Option (2) might be more appealing to the relevant editors, though.
> 
> The paper was written in LaTeX using the ICC 2019 template, so it
will
> have to be reformatted for the journal we select, and it might need
to
> be converted to MS Word.  If any of you are fluent in LaTeX I can
send
> the source file to you, but it will be sufficient to send me your
> comments marked up on the PDF, or as notes in an email.  I am quite
> happy to incorporate any comments or suggestions you might have into
the
> text myself.
> 
> For the moment, please try to send me your inputs by Monday 30
> September 2019, so that I can include them in the next version.
> 
> Regards
> Antony
> 
> 
>>>> On 09 September 2019 at 23:57, in message
> <833918554cff419db284f6b3b86182a5 at sdfe.dk>, Jan Hjelmager
> <jnh at sdfe.dk>
> wrote:
>> Hi Serena and Antony
>> I have two question. What is the timeline for producing the paper,
> and when 
>> do you need a reply as to if one can contribute?
>> 
>> Best regards
>> Jan
>> 
>> 
>> Jan Hjelmager
>> Specialist consultant
>> Methodology and IT
>> 
>> D. +45 7254 5115
>> M. +45 4129 3036
>> E. jnh at sdfe.dk<mailto:jnh at sdfe.dk>
>> 
>> [cid:image001.png at 01D18F45.01BF1370]
>> 
>> The Danish Agency for Data Supply and Efficiency
>> 
>> Rentemestervej 8
>> 2400 Copenhagen NV
>> Denmark
>> 
>> T. +45 7254 5500
>> W. www.sdfe.dk<http://www.sdfe.dk/>
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> Fra: ICA-SDIStandards <ica-sdistandards-bounces at lazarus.elte.hu> På
> vegne af 
>> Serena Coetzee
>> Sendt: 9. september 2019 20:11
>> Til: Ica-sdistandards at lazarus.elte.hu 
>> Emne: [Ica-sdistandards] Contribute to a paper about the ICA model
of
> 
>> stakeholders in an SDI?
>> 
>> Dear Commission members,
>> 
>> Antony Cooper, a former Chair of our Commission on SDI & Standards,
> would 
>> like to invite Commission members to contribute to a paper about
the
> ICA 
>> model of stakeholders in a spatial data infrastructure (SDI). The
> idea is 
>> that this will be a paper from our Commission, so any of you are
> welcome to 
>> contribute.
>> 
>> Attached is the latest version of a paper provisionally entitled "A
> review 
>> of the ICA model of stakeholders in a spatial data infrastructure
> (SDI)".  A 
>> preliminary version of this paper was presented at ICC 2019,
entitled
> 
>> "Expanding the ICA model of stakeholders in a spatial data
> infrastructure 
>> (SDI) ".  For the abstract of that presentation, see: 
>> https://www.abstr-int-cartogr-assoc.net/1/49/2019/. The list of
> authors for 
>> the ICC 2019 abstract is all those who worked on the model during
the
> 
>> Commission meeting in Dresden, August 2013.
>> 
>> The attached paper is primarily a review of the literature that
used
> the 
>> Commission's SDI models and a consolidation of the suggested
> improvements to 
>> the SDI stakeholder model.  This paper also includes a figure
showing
> all the 
>> 45 types and subtypes of a stakeholder in an SDI that were included
> in the 
>> Commission's paper at ICC 2011 in Paris (a separate, larger copy of
> the 
>> figures is also attached).  This attached paper also includes a
table
> from 
>> the 2008 IJGIS paper (that might or might not have any relevance)
and
> the 
>> expanded SDI stakeholder model from the Dresden meeting, which is
> clearly 
>> incomplete.
>> 
>> Going forward, there are the following options:
>> 
>> (1) Complete this paper as a review paper, with Section 4. "Summary
> of the 
>> suggested changes to the model" being an overview of the suggested
> changes.  
>> The two tables will then be omitted.
>> 
>> (2) Complete this paper as a review paper, with Section 4. "Summary
> of the 
>> suggested changes to the model" being a consolidation of all the
> suggestions, 
>> producing an update of the figure of the SDI stakeholders.  Again,
> the two 
>> tables will then be omitted.
>> 
>> (3) Split this paper into two papers, one being the review and the
> other 
>> being the new SDI stakeholder model, incorporating all the
suggested
> 
>> improvements, completing Table 2: Expanded SDI stakeholder model
(the
> Dresden 
>> results) and producing an update of the figure of the SDI
> stakeholders.  This 
>> second paper will take a lot more effort.
>> 
>> If you would like to contribute to one of these papers (and hence
be
> a 
>> co-author), please contact Antony Cooper 
>> acooper at csir.co.za<mailto:acooper at csir.co.za>
>> 
>> Regards,
>> Serena
>> 
>> Serena Coetzee (GPr GISc 1245)
>> University of Pretoria
>> Professor and Head of Department Geography, Geoinformatics and
> Meteorology
>> Geography Building 1-3.7, Hatfield Campus, Lynnwood Road, Hatfield,
> 0083, 
>> South Africa
>> email: serena.coetzee at up.ac.za<mailto:serena.coetzee at up.ac.za> ·
Web:
> 
>> www.up.ac.za/ggm<http://www.up.ac.za/ggm> · Mobile: +27 82 464 4294
·
> Tel: +27 
>> 12 420 3823
>> 
>> Stakeholder analysis of the governance framework of a national SDI
> dataset * 
>> whose needs are met in the buildings and address register of the 
>>
>
Netherlands?<https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17538947.2018.15209

> 
>>30>
>> Geographic Information Metadata*An Outlook from the International 
>> Standardization Perspective<https://www.mdpi.com/2220-9964/8/6/280>