MEETING 1-91 in Szentendre, Hungary
Minutes summary, IOF MC Ordinary meeting: 1-91
Time: 1991-03-23
Place: Szentendre, Hungary
Participants: Thomas Brogli (SUI, chair), Jorma Ake (FIN), Andreas Dresen (GER),
Flemming Norgaard (DEN), Mark Smith (CAN), Gyula Szabó (HUN)
Apologies: Robin Harvey (GBR), Tore Kristiansen (NOR).
Present as observer: Zdenek Lenhart (CZE), László Zentai (HUN)
1a. Opening of meeting
Meeting opened 09:00 hours
The Chairperson welcomes all representatives to Hungary. Particularly pleased
to welcome representatives from host country Hungary and Czehoslovakia.
1b. Minutes of last meeting - Steikjer, Norway
Minutes of the last meeting approved.
2. Reports from Council meetings and IOF Committees
- IOF Council News affecting the Map Committee
A proposal has been introduced that would reduce the workload and particularly
the duplication of Council tasks by reorganising Council responsibilities and
committees. TB summarizes proposal:
Council will be responsible for developing policy only (i.e. thinking)
Committees will be responsible for implementing policy (i.e. action)
Council members will be assigned areas of responsibiltiy:
External relations: President and Vice-President
Internal relations: Regional representatives
Long Range Planning: Sue Harvey and Ake J.
Co-ordination of Clinics: Hugh Cameron and Sarolta Monspart. This will reduce
duplication of efforts by DPC, MC and TC.
- DPC Clinic in Romania
DPC had planned clinic for mid-March but schedule did not allow suitable time
for mapping.
TB has had contact with Romania regarding an IOF Map Clinic there. Nicolaie Stroiescu
responded that there are no funds to cover cost of accommodation for instructors.
TB indicated that simple acommodation in people homes would be satisfactory.
- World Cup Group Report
WCG asks MC to name monitors for 1992 World Cup events.
- Technical Committee Proposal regarding "Out of bounds" symbols
TC has proposed two kinds of borders for OOB areas:
Dashed line - OOB area not marked in terrain
Solid line - OOB area marked (i.e. by ribbons) in terrain
MC feels that TC has responsibility for overprint features, including definition
of how to use boundary lines for OOB areas. MC has responsibiliy for map features.
MC can add changes to OOB boundary guidelines to ISOM. Current standards are reflected
in latest issue of ISOM.
3. Letters
From Sarolta Monspart (variety of topics)
Regarding point 3.4 (Yugoslavia), the MC agrees that where possible the instructor
should be from a neighbouring country, however political situations must be considered
in choosing who will go. The political situation in Romania indicated that a Czech
instructor would be more appropriate than a Hungarian.
The MC also notes that map instructors should be from a country with similar conditions
and problems OR be very familiar with conditions and problems of host country.
4. ISOM Working Group Report
Robin Harvey not available to provide news on publishing of ISOM. Will send fax
at break. FN circulates b&w and colour proofs.
- New format
The new computerized format will assist countries in producing their own translated
versions of ISOM. Several federations (DAN, SUI, GER, NOR, FIN) already have plans
to do it.
-Distribution information
Proposing same price as last edition (i.e. SKR 20). Will send 10 free copies to
member countries. The MC will make available to member federations film, with
or without text, at cost. FN suggests TB write a letter to member federations
regarding these items.
-German translation
TB will attempt to finish the German version on MacIntosh (because that is what
original was created on) and welcomes comments about translation from committee
members who do not speak German as a first language.
5. Mapping Activity Reports from Member Federations
Switzerland
TB reports that Swiss Federation is making own copy of ISOM in conjunction with
German Federation, with insert for special Swiss symbols. TB handed out several
maps produced with OCAD. Hans Steinegger (developer of OCAD) had session with
Swiss mappers. TB also handed out map prepared using AutoCAD. Produced by Ueli
Schlatter output by plotter, ink on drafting film, screen applied conventionally).
He is doing maps fro next Swiss 6-day using this method.
Finland
JA reports that new requirements in place for maps at various scales (1:5000,
1:10000 and 1:15000) at 11 sports institutes in Finland. A three year production
cycle has been started. Similar project for preparation of approx. 55 maps on
or around Finnish military bases.
Canada
MS reports that interest in computer cartography is growing but that few competition
quality orienteering maps have been produced by non-professionals. Both OCAD and
Mac methods used. Relatively fewer o-maps produced in Canada in recent years and
very few mappers producing.
Germany
AD reports that 15-20 mappers now using OCAD. Meeting was held to compare OCAD
and Illustrator/MacIntosh options. Political reunion of east and west has indicated
some conflict regarding mapping standards.
Czechoslovakia
ZL reports that TCH wanted only 3 mappers to work on World Championship maps to
maintain quality and consistency, but this means maps may not be printed one year
ahead of time as required. Capitalism has created interest in the development
of private mapping firms. Some TCH mappers are working out of country to earn
hard currency, therefore there are few quality mappers at home. Each year approximately
100 new maps are created of which 30 are for developing orienteering (i.e. simple
maps).
Hungary
GS reports that computer cartography is just getting started. OCAD is most popular
because Macs not available until recent months. Technology in general is not available
due to economic problems (as for neighbouring countries). LZ has produced the
first OCAD map, Lajosforrás, near meeting site. There is some concern about
how the Fedration will obtain funds if most maps made by clubs and private people.
There are also few map-makers because they cannot support their families by mapping
works.
Denmark
FN reports that computer cartography is developing quickly. MacIntosh method is
most popular due to early start and low sophistication of early OCAD versions.
Seven clubs have bought Mac systems and the Federation bought a Mac system for
the Danish Map Committee. There has been some problem in deciding how federation
will get funds when maps are made by clubs. In the past the DOF controlled printing
but now colour photocopying and computer output makes control difficult. To compensate
there is a move to increase the levy on competitions. Cost of producing both 1:15000
and 1:10000 scale maps for each area so experiments have been conducted with photocopy
enlargments. Appears to work well. Also experimenting with producing color laser
printed school maps and giving one copy to school at no charge.
6. Publications
There have been plans to produce two publications in addition to existing ISOM:
a. Photogrammetry
b. Computer Mapping
Photogrammetry
FN shows Danish book on photogrammetry. Perhaps we could translate the relevant
parts and produce them as an MC booklet. TB will ask Secretariat to translate
sections before the summer meeting. Copies of the translation will be sent to
MC members wiht instructions to brings detailed comments to summer meeting.
Computer Mapping
TB suggests we use Hi-Tech Report as model for MC publication. FN will ask Finn
Arildsen about this possibility.
7. Instructor's Conference 1991, Detailed Programme
General informations
Scheduled for Marianské Lázne, Czechoslovakia, Friday August 16th
to Sunday August 18th, 1991. An advertisement was received by MC members and will
be inserted in Orienteering World magazine.
Reservations have been made for 70 people. The fee for one representative from
each federation is DM20 to encourage involvement, additional participants DM160.
TB requests that registration be sent directly to Dr. Jan Pichal in Czechoslovakia
but that national totals also be sent to TB.
MC members must let TB know they are not going by June 15th otherwise reservation
will be made for them. There is no charge to MC members for conference.
Special topics
These are items of particular interest that will be presented to delegates. TB
wants to assign responsibilities to MC members.
a. ISOM
Designed to familiarise participants with the new specifications. Responsibility
FN and/or Robin Harvey.
b. Survey and Interpretation of Vegetation in Continental Terrain
There still appears to be a lot of confusion about how to use green and combinations
of symbols. The chart in ISOM clarifies this but a discussion will assist mappers.
Map of area needed. Responsibility AD.
c. Computer Cartography
Depends on availability of computers in Czechoslovakia. ZL will look into the
possibility and contact TB. Responsibility FN, RH and MS for Mac; Hans Steinegger
for OCAD and Laszlo Zentai.
d. Models for instruction of Beginner Map-makers
An opportunity to introduce ideas from different countries about techniques for
teaching beginning map-makers. Responsibility TB.
8. Map courses
1991
Romania - Money not available for accommodation of instructors. Shall MC make
exception to rule that says host Federation pays accommodation for instructors.
MC agrees that rule will stand but that in special circumstences, such as Romania,
the MC will pay the accommodation fee. Appears that a french speaking instructors
is ideal but only TB speaks acceptable French. TB and AD probable instructors,
perhaps LZ also. Tentatively scheduled for Spring 1992.
1992
Canada - MS requests clinic for October 1992 during week before, during, or after
Toronto area World Cup. 1991 Canadian Championship period ruled out due to scheduling
conflicts. Toronto area ensures access to accommodation, transport and especially
computers. Focus of clinic to be computer cartography.
Europe - TB wants computer cartography clinic for European federations sometime
in 1992. Possible sites: Denmark (FN coordinates) or Czechoslovakia, University
of Brno (ZL coordinates). MC members should bring information sufficient to make
decisions at summer meeting.
1993-95
New Zealand - FN indicates interest in clinic. TB will contact them.
USA - MS suggests there may be value or interest in map clinic before, during
or after 1993 World Championships.
Other
TB will prepare invitation to member federations to submit requests for Map Clinics,
to be included in upcoming Oreienteering World.
9. Activity Plan for 1991
4th International Instructor's Conference for O-Mapping (Friday, August 16th -
Sunday, August 18th, 1991)
Photogrammetry manual
Computer Mapping Manual
10. World Cup Monitoring 1992
Reports coming in:
Canada - preliminary report form organizers circulated. Project appears well underway,
however MS expressed early concerns about cartographic portion of production.
Neither method nor person chosen yet. MS will monitor.
Sweden - alternative to Toby Stenbeck required by Sweden for their World Cup.
MC recommends FN or JA.
11. Next Meeting
Sunday, August 18th, 1991
Marianské Lázne, Czechoslovakia
12. Other Business
TB hands out demo OCAD 3.0 and written description sheets.
To contact to Flemming Norgaard: work - 45 86202711 ext.2514, fax: 45 86139326
13. Meeting Adjourned
17:55 hours